American Idol Season 5 – Katharine McPhee audition

I wonder what Simon thinks of Smash

@theQuestion626 ignorant opinions*****

I always said she was the Judy Garland for this century. Watch her go to the top, now. This is fun. So many voted against her back then because pretty girls often don’t do well on “Idol”. Well, somebody noticed and she’s on her way. Wow! So glad I was right!

@theQuestion626 I’m sorry your private school made you hate pretty women. However, you need to stop generalizing. If you assume “she’s pretty therefore she’s a slut”, you give her no chance to prove herself otherwise. And then, of course, she doesn’t. That’s a vicious cycle of confirming your opinions without proof, again and again. It’s hard, but try giving people a chance. You’ll be surprised! There are LOTS of great (and beautiful) women out there who work very, very hard to be good people.

@theQuestion626 No, you’re wrong again… there’s one thing you’re better than her at, and THAT would be sucking dick! BAAHHAHAHA!!! Sorry! Forgive me for not seeing that you were better than her in some way!

@Asiandudefosho have you ever met a woman that was even remotely close to McPhee physical attributes that wasn’t, in some way shape and form a slut? Have you seen the private schools that are along the same plane that McPhee attended? I have. And let me tell you this: all girls that are of significant physical beauty are very promiscious, selfish, arrogant as well as egotistical.

@Asiandudefosho if you honestly believe McPhee made her career based on anythign OTHER than her looks and sexual prowess than you’re more deluded and equally as pathetic than what you accuse me of being. Regardless….hey, enjoy her, she’ll be replaced by another sex object with a sweet voice and stunning figure. Happens all the time. The entertainment industry is built on such whores.

@theQuestion626 What the hell are you talking about? First off, how is she a slut? Secondly, Talentless slut? Lmao. She’s brilliant in many ways including her voice. She’s also appeared in several acting gigs. Apparently your delusional and deaf? You’re points are invalid in every way. You’re pathetic.

@djbarcode5xyz Upstaged by a woman who can make a career solely based on her looks and cuz she can carry a tune? Well I dare say this woman has accomplished what is essentially the modern American Dream. She is nothing more than just an object of sexual gratification who’s rise to “stardom” is based on the aforementioned physical attributes. SHe has no genuine talents, though I’m sure she sucks a mean dick.

Who would have thought she would go from this to a tv series that is most likely going to be a “Smash” hit, pardon the pun lol. She is amazing, always has been.

She’s so cute!! Can’t wait to see more of her in Smash.

Just watched the first episode of Smash on Hulu and i am SO excited for this show. I forgot how amazing her voice is. I’ll be watching every single episode

Simon is not a douche at all. Simon was the only honest one there, and he brought a stern, yet impressionable act to the table, that American Idol really needed. If people want to complain the “Simon was mean to them”, they need to shut re fuck up, and take his well placed advice into consideration.